Sick(o) in America

John Stossel picks up the gauntlet that Micheal Moore threw down, and slaps him silly with it; in less time than it takes to watch the over-rated 'documentary' Sicko. Here's a quote from the online article:

There are many problems with health insurance, but that doesn't mean we should put the government in control. If it's decided that health care should be paid for with tax dollars, then it's up to the government to decide how that money should be spent. There's only so much money to go around, so the inevitable result is rationing.

It's just the law of supply and demand. Lowering prices increases demand. Lowering the price to nothing pushes demand through the roof. Author P.J. O'Rourke said it best: "If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs when it's free."

When health care is free, governments deal with all that increased demand by limiting what's available.

read more | digg story

I have watched both Sicko and Stossel's 20/20 special. While the interviews with the individuals struggling with the problems of the healthcare system were emotionally compelling in Sicko; as usual, the emotional argument is used to blind the viewer to the real culprit in the problem.

Sick in America, John Stossel's response to Sicko, lacks none of the passion that Micheal Moore pours into his film, and yet deals in clear truths and verifiable facts. He discovers the real culprit behind the healthcare crisis. The real culprit is government.

The Canadians lamenting the lack of insurance coverage in the US is a classic example of using emotion to obscure the real problem. Why doesn't the Canadian socialized system pay for services rendered in the US? Or any other country? If it was truly free service for their citizens, it would be free wherever the need arose. This is true of all the socialized healthcare systems across the world. There is no charge to the end user, provided he goes to a funded provider; and that's the catch. The government pays for the service through taxes, and rations the healthcare that is available based on the funds that are provided.

[this is also why drugs are cheaper in other countries. Prices are artificially lowered through agreements with those countries single payer systems. This should explain why the pharmaceutical companies don't want to you to import Canadian drugs into the US. At some point they will simply stop providing the medication at reduced prices, since they can no longer profit from it's production. Profit is why anyone engages in business in the first place, and healthcare is a business.]

The one thing Moore got correct in Sicko was the scathing criticism of the current health insurance system. Once again, he missed the real culprit. Government regulation has created the current health insurance system. HMO, PPO, etc; just more three letter acronyms for government created systems. If you agree to be covered by an HMO, then they, like the government in other countries, tell you who can treat you and for what.

I love the fact that he spent so much time in Europe. What a beacon of economic health France and the other European economies are. I also love the way he never addresses how much they pay in taxes for the lavish services provided. Sadly, it's not that much more than we do here in the US for the lack of services that we have. That doesn't mean we should pay more for better service. Logic should dictate that we demand to pay less, and provide our own 'safety net'.

Let's make something clear here; we are not Kaiser Permanente (Moore's whipping boy of choice) In fact, the health care industry itself is not Kaiser Permanente. Based on the criminal behavior documented concerning Kaiser Permanente, I would think there would be charges filed somewhere against them. But then, their behavior is regulated and endorsed by the government. The same government that Moore thinks we should hand over the rest of healthcare to.

Only a dedicated socialist, like Micheal Moore, would consider it an indictment that we provide healthcare to prisoners, people held against their will (and as far as Gitmo detainees are concerned, held without charges) prisoners have no ability to provide for themselves, while citizens of the US do without healthcare; and, of course, the Cuban government bent over backward at Moore's request to treat his boatload of sick people. What a media coup that is. Cuba heals the sick overlooked by America's evil capitalist system; especially the neglected Ground Zero workers.

[My sister spent several years at Ground Zero, helping with the clean up effort. She, along with thousands of others still suffer from the after effects of being exposed to the air around Ground Zero; health problems that the government still denies has anything to do with working at Ground Zero. The government has lead the way towards disenfranchising those heroes of Ground Zero. The insurance companies are simply following the government's lead, just like they always have.]

Except, of course, that the system might be evil, but it most certainly isn't capitalist. All of the government managed systems are no different from the fascist corporatism of Il Duce's Italy; just another variant of socialism. Yes, the system currently in place is already a compromise. See how well it's working? Don't you want more of the same?

I'd like to speak for a significant portion of America's uninsured. We don't want universal health care. Some of us are uninsured by choice. The cost of insurance outweighs the benefit provided by insurance. (The only way the cost is justifiable is if a family member has some long term expensive-to-treat disease, and then the insurance company disallows coverage based on some obscure clause in the policy. I have seen this happen before) Forcing us to contribute to a universal system through a greater tax burden will simply drive us further into poverty. We want the freedom to choose what we want insured, and to get the same tax benefits as any other insurance provider. We want to negotiate prices directly with our doctors and hospitals, and we want the choice to remain uninsured if we deem it necessary.

Let charity provide the 'free' services. Only charity really can. All other arrangements involve the use of force on one or another of various groups. This is unacceptable to those of us who believe force should not be involved in normal social relationships.



It's worth mentioning that I followed the sentiment of Micheal Moore in his film, and refused to pay for the privilege of viewing his film, just as he does not wish to pay for the privilege of getting healthcare service. Instead I found an alternative source for the material. Anybody with access to a torrent program may do the same. I don't reward thieves for promoting government as their method of choice.

John Stossel's special has been broken into segments and is available on YouTube. Let him know you support his views by contacting him at ABC.

digg story

There's also a blog entry over at Downsize DC on the subject of the healthcare system, as well as an entire section of the website over at CATO.

CATO Weekly Video on the subject of "Sicko"

There really is no excuse to be uninformed on the subject.

2 comments:

  1. Anonymous9:43 PM

    Another American who hasn't done their homework. Canada does not have socialized health care. It has provincial health care. In other words, each province does things its own way. It is not national. This is a long-standing myth in the US.

    ReplyDelete
  2. And another nit-picking socialist who thinks he has a point feels compelled to comment.

    It's too bad that basic education in the Great White North isn't more thorough, or my detractor might realize that provincial health care is still socialized medicine because it is funded with tax dollars taken from the average citizen; which is the definition of socialized. It doesn't matter what level of gov't enacts the policy, it only matters that government funds it with tax dollars (which it does in Canada) Pity he didn't look that one up first.

    ReplyDelete

Ad Hominems, Spam and Advertisements will be mercilessly deleted. All other comments are eagerly anticipated.