Connect America = Control of the Internet

It's not making much news, but Hillary Clinton has a proposal that should have all of us running away from her in abject terror.

No, it's not the completely predictable proposal to force us all to pay for health insurance (that's a yawner, from where I'm sitting) it's the story being reported in this AP news story:
Presidential hopeful Hillary Rodham Clinton on Wednesday called for a national broadband Internet system and permanent research tax credits...

"The nation that invented the Internet is now ranked about 25th in access to it," Clinton said in her latest speech directed at the middle class appeals.

Called "Connect America," Clinton's broadband network would give businesses incentives to go into underserved areas, support state- and local-based initiatives and change the Federal Communication Commission rules to more accurately measure Internet access.
Can we say FCC as a national internet service provider (ISP)? If a federal agency is given authority over the internet, can there be any doubt that they will become the ultimate ISP, and govern the internet as they govern television and radio broadcast. Even beyond that, rules changes allowing FCC regulation of the internet will give the FCC regulation of cable television as well.

Let's imagine, shall we, that the self same government agency that has so famously declared certain words as unspeakable over the airwaves, and certain body parts as unviewable on television, can now determine what will or will not be acceptable on the internet.

Obviously there will be no more porn (and no more porn channels on pay-per-view, either) but that's just the start. How about access to information on sex education? How about medical journals? And why stop there? How about an internet 'fairness doctrine'. Political forums would be subject to requirements concerning equal times on the forum for dissenting views, or be faced with closure.

But that's also only the surface. This is where the real money is. Access to all materials that have 'cloudy' licensing issues will be blocked. Peer to peer will be history. Torrents a thing of the past. If you want music or movies, software or whatever, you will have to go to the license holders and pay whatever price they ask. No more testing on the QT to make sure the product will work for you, not unless you can find someone with a duplicatible hard copy. No more catching that missed episode of you favorite TV show by accessing a torrent file.

"Follow the money" the saying goes, and I think I can spot where the money is coming from, and where it will be going, if Hillary gets her wish on this issue. Forget socialized medicine; we're talking basic information access here.

But that's also just the tip of the iceberg. Putting the gov't in charge of internet access puts us in the same category as China; where anything the gov't doesn't approve of will be blocked. It opens up the door to a 1984 type scenario where information and history are completely malleable, where truth is whatever those in charge deem it to be at any given moment (we have always been at war with Eastasia...) because they can simply dictate that the records be changed, and there won't even be the gaping holes in the photographs next to Stalin to point out that something is missing.

Is anyone still so naive as to think that once the camel's nose is under the tent that the whole camel won't shortly follow? That giving the gov't the ability to provide access to the internet won't eventually lead to active control of content? It's happening now everywhere the gov't is involved; the internet will be no different, and is already no different in places where internet access is provided at gov't expense; the attempts to control content in libraries are a shining example of this.

We should run screaming from suggestions such as the one floated by Ms. Clinton. Better yet, we should vow never to listen to (much less elect) someone with such a shaky notion of what real freedom is.

digg story

No comments:

Post a Comment

Ad Hominems, Spam and Advertisements will be mercilessly deleted. All other comments are eagerly anticipated.